. . .
The world had turned upside down. Motörhead were opening for Slayer, who were opening for Slipknot – and I didn’t need earplugs. As three figures dotted a distant stage, “Ace of Spades” floated through the air, then dissipated halfway towards us. My friends and I stood on the lawn in back of the San Manuel Amphitheater in San Bernardino, California. We could comfortably hold a conversation, and that was wrong.
Even worse, it was daylight. The sights weren’t pretty. The Amphitheater afforded great views of the San Gabriel Mountains, but we were focused on our immediate 20-foot radius. At any point, any of these things could have entered it: drunks, brawlers, Korn t-shirts, impromptu mosh pits, projectile vomit, plastic trash fires (escalating in size, number, and acridity as night fell – you don’t know terror until you’re in the dark, surrounded by blazing fires and thousands of people singing along to Slipknot), males openly sporting Nazi insignia, children-with-sisters-or-mothers-one-couldn’t-tell-which. As Buzz Osborne of Melvins said about ZZ Top’s audience: “If you could stack up all the warrants that were due in the crowd… Jesus!”
Jesus was not in the house tonight. (If he had been, water would have been cheaper.) To drive home the point, a man in front of me wore a t-shirt that said, “Dios no está aquí” (“God is not here”). God probably gave up on this corner of creation.
Naturally, Slayer started with “Disciple”, whose refrain is “God hates us all”. Marshall cabs formed a backdrop of two large inverted crosses: clever. A friend of mine once referred to Slayer shows as the closest metalheads get to going to church. It’s true. Instead of “Amazing Grace” and “Holy, Holy, Holy”, the hymns are “Angel of Death” and “Piece by Piece”. Most everyone knows the first verse and fakes it through the rest. People dress up and convene, repeat words like mantras (“Jesus-uh”, “Slayerrrrrrrrr”), and pay for a performance of fire and brimstone. It’s like the Super Bowl for most: pick a side and enjoy the snacks.
I actually enjoyed no snacks or refreshments during Slayer. This was because my head was trying to rip itself out of my body. Low volume and grim setting be damned, Slayer tore it up like they still had something to prove. Live, Dave Lombardo and Kerry King have never disappointed me. Those guys can play. Even from a quarter mile away, you could feel Lombardo pushing and pulling songs. “War Ensemble” thundered like angry horses. “Dead Skin Mask” sounded the best I’ve ever heard it live – slow, deliberate, creepy. King was a precision saw, and Tom Araya hit most of his screams.
When I talk about these details, I probably sound like Deadheads arguing about which version of “Mississippi Half-Step” was better, Boston ‘73 or Santa Fe ‘82. Maybe you’ve been doing Bikram yoga for 10 years, the same 26 poses week in and week out – and goshdarnit, that April 3 class in 2007 really blew your mind. It’s all about the ritual. You do it regularly because you subscribe to the system. Whether that system is God, Satan, the Dead, Slayer, yoga, or Sunday football, you find meaning in in it. Usually it ranges from OK to good – otherwise you wouldn’t keep coming back – but every once in a while it’s better than sex, and you remember again why you signed up.
Surprisingly, the reason why San Bernardino ‘12 will stick with me was Gary Holt. The Exodus guitarist filled in for Jeff Hanneman, who almost singlehandedly ruined the last Slayer show I saw (Long Beach ‘10). Hanneman’s playing then was a sloppy mess. It left a bad taste in my mouth, and not just because Slayer tickets aren’t cheap. Slayer are supposed to be invulnerable live. You anticipate the show and obsess over the setlist because the payoff is so big: Slayer channel metal thunder. They don’t just look it or act like it. When the lights go down and the first note hits, a Slayer room changes chemistry. For a limited time – in this case, an all-too-brief hour – Slayer channel elemental forces and share them with us. We can forget daily life and touch the beyond. This might sound a bit mystical, but it’s true. If a Slayer show doesn’t make you feel bigger than you are, check your pulse.
Hanneman was sidelined by an arm injury this time, so Holt did his job: raising pulses. He nailed the rhythm parts, nailed the squiggly Slayer leads, and bounded around like he owned the stage. Funny thing was, he didn’t. He was playing songs that weren’t his, with a band that wasn’t his, to crowds much bigger than his. I wonder how that felt. If he had mixed feelings, it didn’t show. Holt was a true professional and delivered Slayer music. He was exactly what the music required.
Classical music privileges the composition over the performer. A great orchestra can elevate a composition to the sublime, but so can another orchestra in another century. The composition is a monument that performers temporarily borrow. Slayer aren’t of that tradition. They’re part of metal, and thus part of rock music, and thus part of whatever “popular music” is. In popular music, the performer is inextricably tied to the composition. No matter how good a Judas Priest tribute band is, you’ll always prefer the real thing, because it has Rob and Glenn and K.K. But for a moment this night, while watching Holt be Slayer, I wondered if Slayer were subject to the same rules. Must Slayer music die when Slayer hang it up? The recordings might live on, but the ritual doesn’t. The parking lot filled with shouts of “Slayer”, the timeless denim warriors, the change in state from fan observer to ritual participant – those will go away. I wish it weren’t so.
The harmonies of “Raining Blood” arced through the air and filled me with a charge. Involuntarily, I raised my arms, shook my fists at the sky, and cried, “FUCK YES”.
. . .




br>
Excellent!
wonderful article.
You hit the nail on the head about Hanneman’s playing (I saw them in ‘10 also). It was so, SO disappointing, which was sad, when everything else was on point. They played the entirety of the Seasons album, which was big to me growing up as a young guitarist, and I wanted nothing more than to hear Hanneman nail the solo in Seasons (the song), as I dug it so much. Nothing doing. It sounded like warmed over piss.
Awesome concert review. I especially liked your thoughts on Gary Holt and how we was able to merge with the band.
Even though this doesn’t cover the Slipknot set, I read ( probably on Blabbermouth) that their Bass replacement is required to play backstage, behind a screen. As he is not a ‘member’ I think it was Corey Taylor who said that he didn’t ‘have the right to play alongside with the rest of the band. I thought this was pretty horrible, so the Holt story shows that perhaps Slayer doesn’t have the issues with ego and control?
Wait….would you want to be seen on stage with Slipknot?
I think Slipknot are too wrapped up in this WE and US vs THEM thing that makes them appeal to 14 year olds. It’s not even a control thing most likely… I bet somewhere some awkward kid who love him some ICP and Slipknot thinks “Damn right he doesn’t get to be onstage”… and that’s why they do it. Slipknot is brilliance in metal marketing, no more, no less.
Also, saw Anthrax, Megadeth and Slayer in Baltimore 2 years ago, the other 2 bands should not have been allowed within 10 miles of Slayer. Period. They fuckin’ destroyed. My neck hurt so bad after wards… So bad, but so good.
I don’t know, man. In Slipknot’s defense, Jeff Hanneman is injured and their bassist is fucking dead. While I think that Cory Taylor quote is lame–didn’t read it, but if it’s true, yeah, what an ass–I thought the lack of a bassist during their set said something, and thought it was at least cool that they were willing to do that.
True, true.
The rumor I heard from a friend who was backstage (I was at this show, reliving my nightmares from my Top 3 Terrifying Shows post, as this was the same location as the Slayer show I wrote about) is that someone in the band’s spleen had burst so he was sidelined for a while. Word was that the fill-ins were just members of Whitechapel who had played earlier in the day, and that, yes they were behind the stage just shredding along. I wouldn’t be surprised if it was true, but this also came a week after the supposed spleen-bursting. Not much time to get a giant jumpsuit and custom mask rigged up. I wouldn’t expect them to have a normal dude on stage.
But yeah, Slipknot are still horrible.
“…their Bass replacement is required to play backstage, behind a screen…”
NO SHIT!!
Imagine Jason Newsted playing behind a screen for all these years… Or Paul Bostaph… or, hey, the whole of Dave Mustaine’s band!!!!
I saw Slayer open for Rob Zombie last summer at an outdoor venue in Pittsburgh. Their set began at 7 prompt, in waning daylight. It definitely felt strange to see Slayer playing in something other than pitch blackness. Regardless, they killed. It was my first live experience with the band and I was shocked at how good they sounded. Araya was on point, Lombardo was intense and precise and King and Holt were a great combo. Not seeing Henneman and his bloated, Nazi loving face was okay with me. As for the crowd: if you ever wanted to rob a trailer park, that was your night.
I saw Slayer at Mayhem last week and last year at the Big 4 show at Yankee Stadium. In both instances, once they hit the stage everything was transformed. A tepid amphitheater turned into a gladiatorial pit of blood thirst. Casual observers had to walk out because they couldn’t wrap their heads around the primal deluge of metal at it’s most proficient and pointed. Slayer is the best. Even with Gary Holt they still feel like Slayer (sorry Jeff). I mean they had Paul Bostaph behind the kit for a while and they were still Slayer, though King and Araya are irreplaceable. I was with a friend who had never seen them live before and after every song he only had one word to say….”Fuck!” After EVERY song. No other band comes close. SSSLLLLLAAAYYYYEEEEEERRRRRR!
Great review of Slayer. But what about Slipknot? C’mon, we’re all wondering just how much they sucked!
I ducked out after a handful of Slipknot songs. Having not listened to Slipknot on purpose in a long time (well, really ever), I somehow forgot how much pseudo-rapping happens during the verses. The “SICK/BRUTAL” parts sounded appropriately sick and brutal, I guess. Also, the DJ. Lots of horrendous scratching and awkward samples happening constantly. No metal band needs a DJ. No band with guitars needs a DJ, as far as I’m concerned.
It’s good to remind yourself that the things you hate do in fact suck as much as you always assumed.
NO ONE should legally be allowed to play over Slayer OR Motorhead ever under any circumstances…least of all silly ass Slipknot.
1 pro: you get to go home early, right?
that is definitely a pro for the dad-fraction which i am part of. i love it if there’s great openers and shit headliners.
In Slipknot’s defense, I would think that was pretty weak if I cared about Slipknot.
Is the new bass player also named “Corey” or “Tiffany” or something like that, or did they get someone with a name like Robert Johnathon Pierce II to make sure there wouldn’t be any confusion?
I hope Slayer and Motorhead were well paid.
Great review.
It’s pretty amazing how Slayer live is still such an other-worldly experience this far into their careers. The rest of the big four can’t even begin to hold a candle to them at this point. There are a lot of older bands that I hear people say they have no interest in seeing anymore, but Slayer isn’t one of them.
I caught them at the Mayhem fest two years ago where I thought they were suffering the even greater indignity of opening for Marlyn Manson, although they seemed to have had the last laugh when pretty much the entire place cleared out after they finished.
The self-righteous indignation of tr00 metalheads hating Slipknot will never not be funny and sad. Sounds like it was a hell of a Slayer show.
I pretty much agree. I grew up during the thrash heyday and while I’m not a Slipknot fan anymore they did bring me back to the metal after I largely got away from it in college. That first album was pretty damn good. I just ignore them now. No need to hate bands you don’t even listen to.
Very good review. Got a few laughs out of me, too. And the second to last paragraph raises a very interesting question: “Must Slayer music die when Slayer hang it up?”
It reminds me of when Motorhead went on an insulting and degrading tour opening for Foo Fighters, a horrible overrated band that banks on their audience not having the musical knowledge their repackaging front man does.
Rockstar Mayhem Festival? Chuckle. Slipknot fans? Chuckle chuckle. San Bernardino, the meth ridden, putrid ass of the earth? Chuckle chuckle chuckle.
You can see where I’m going with this.