. . .
Production choices can say a lot about a band. Crystalline precision often signifies a desire to communicate — notes are clear because you want the listener to hear each and every note. For certain styles of technical metal, clean production is an unsubtle way of saying “look what I can do”, or “worship at the altar of my skills”. Mainstream metal can be similarly clear, but the production serves to hammer home the hooks, as if you could somehow miss an anthemic chorus that repeats 16 times.
Historically speaking, lo-fi production usually meant the band couldn’t afford anything better — they sounded like shit because they had no other option. As time marches on, technology follows suit, and it gets cheaper along the way. These days you can find professional recording software for practically nothing (see Reaper), and affordable amp and FX modeling gear can sound surprisingly good. For most bands of the modern age, sounding like shit is a choice. Bands may have varying reasons as to why they choose the lo-fi route – in order to create atmosphere and mystery, to obscure mediocre playing, or to emulate the clatter of the lo-fi originators and their primitive gear – but the art of sounding like shit is alive and well in 2012.
On Sielunvihollinen, Förgjord take an interesting approach: by harnessing the un-power of horrendous production, they effectively subvert the ambition of their own songs. Guitars sound like dying transistor radios. Drums rattle along, perfectly capturing the ‘warmth’ of a concrete rehearsal space. The bass is actually audible (and distorted to hell), but it lacks any semblance of low end. “Sounds like raw black metal!”, you say. But the composition of these songs is at odds with their execution. Persistent threads of epic heavy metal pop up across the album, in both the song structures and the melodic composition. Slow, quasi-doom riffs break up long songs that extend through progression rather than repetition. Melodic guitars that may as well have been recorded inside a trashcan faintly underline otherwise blasting riffs.
What might sound cheesy with the weight of modern ‘crushing’ production here works as an interesting affectation, a new way of approaching familiar material. Listening to Förgjord, I keep thinking of Bathory in some imaginary transitional mode, though Sielunvihollinen sounds nothing like Blood Fire Death. Maybe it’s closer to the way Manilla Road play traditional heavy metal: epic ideas are kept in constant check by the feeble production, and somehow, it all works.
Förgjord may not smash expectations, but they’re not shy about experimentation, either. Droning organs and synths appear occasionally, most noticeably under the clean guitar intro of the final track, “Viimeinen Myrsky”, which lends some color to an otherwise grey record. The clean guitar passages might be the weakest point of the album; devoid of tone, and paired with especially loose drumming, these sections are a husk of something that might have been passable. Luckily, once the distortion kicks in it’s easy to forget the whimper before the storm.
I’m curious as to whether the different approaches taken towards production versus songwriting stem from the fact that Förgjord are a two-piece: I like to picture guitarist/bassist Valgrinder trying to squeeze in as many epic riffs as he can, while drummer/vocalist Prokrustes insists the record has too much “tone”. But whatever the reasons, however this thing came to exist and sound the way it does, at least the collision of songwriting and barrel-scraping production generates enough friction to give us some stirring material.
. . .
HEAR SIELUNVIHOLLINEN
. . .
Förgjord – “El Kuoleman Arvoinen”
. . .
. . .
Förgjord – “Niin Lihassa Kuin Veressä”
. . .
. . .
Förgjord – “Sudeksi Syntynyt”
. . .
BUY SIELUNVIHOLLINEN
Amazon (MP3)
Hammer of Hate (CD)
. . .


br>
Thanks for posting this! It is some of the only new black metal I’ve actually enjoyed lately, parts kinda remind me of old Impiety. The mix could be way worse. You can hear all the layers clearly and there isn’t a ton of reverb blurring everything. It all just seems to be taking place within a very narrow frequency range.
I’d be interested to hear about the equipment, methods, and intentions that went into recording and mixing the album. The gap between what us listeners imagine and what the artists actually do can be striking these days. Take the first High Spirits demo for instance. I read at least two reviews that praised the demo for its dirty, old-school analog production, while it was actually done on a computer with DI guitars a drum machine.
Can’t get enough of this style of necro black metal with the cavern reverb although vocals could’ve been pushed back in the mix just a little. Sounds angry but not on the bestial side. Still sounds demo quality, like Armagedda demo material. Worth buying for sure. Why don’t you guys put the label that released the album somewhere near the top of the review?
Reaper is just astounding – cheap, versatile, and better sounding than a lot of the more expensive stuff. I’m not sold on amp sims entirely, though, unless you’re going for a super digital Animals as Leaders sound.
That said, I don’t think this sounds too bad, based on the clips. “Sounds like raw black metal!”, yup. I’m going to have to check this album out…
reaper is indeed the bizzle. provided you have enough cpu juice, a few layers of even free ampsims (acme bar gig is pretty decent) and some other fx can get you a damn interesting/good sound. decent low latency soundcard and you can monitor on the fly with good results.
forgjord is interesting, but i would probably reach for servile sect or sutekh hexen for the gross, lo fi, left field black metal fix.
Not to nerd out too much, but if I use amp sims at all it’s generally layered behind “real” sounds to give some body or color. I don’t think it’s impossible for them to sound convincingly analog, just that we’re not quite there yet. Bar Gig is good, and the Lepou family is very good too. My little guitar input doohickey came with GuitarRig, which is fun to practice with but only really sounds good with LeCab or some other impulse generator behind it.
I’m still learning Reaper, but it’s been great so far. And the price is right!
The good thing about modeling gear is that it’s only getting better. The newer Line 6 HD modelers nail convincing clean tones, and the Pod X3 has had good high gain tones for a while. From what I understand the high end-modelers like Axe FX II and Kemper are extremely good so long as you know how to use them (and can afford them in the first place). Granted, these are all hardware-based modeling solutions. I’m not as familiar with software amp sims other than that a lot of producers exclusively re-amp guitar tracks, which makes me think they must be capable of quality sounds by now.
i can’t speak to guitar playing as i only do synths/samples and whatnot but while none of them have made me wish i hadn’t sold my sherman filterbank rev 1 i’ve found that a few different layers of the acme give me a delightful guitar-ish tone, particularly on the doomy end. if my pc hadn’t died recently i’d be able to up some recent samples somewhere.
i think at this point that most cannot really tell – or even care – that “this is real, this is modeled” is good pudding proof that things have progressed, technology-wise. (or that audiences have regressed, if you like)
Reaper’s great! I’ve used it to record and mix a few projects. I’ve tried Ableton at some stage but didn’t really like it.
The LePou amps are pretty good indeed though I record with a real amp. I think that decent analog-like sounds can be obtained by the right usage digital gear. The guitars on Mayhem’s Ordo Ad Chao was recorded using a Line6 Pod!
sounds like a demo tape I would be crazy about 10 years ago when I was still trading demo-tapes in the underground (which I did it until 2004 or 2005). Unfortunately low-fi eventually gets old and it all start sounding the same after you heard some three or four hundred raw black metal demos… I was trying to remember something that sounds similar to this specific band and I thought of this one: http://www.youtube.com/watch?v=ACqFKIKJW4s but I’m sure there are bands with a much closer sound, just can remember who they are, it feels like I already heard it a thousand times…