http://www.youtube-nocookie.com/v/kBxcZPbP8iQ&hl=en&fs=1&rel=0
My favorite drummers don’t use triggers. Few things kill my buzz like the sight of a drummer futzing with a trigger module. A drummer should come to kill, not to play with MIDI. Here are my six favorite live drum killers. Some have that magic in the studio, too; some don’t. But they all bring the heat in the flesh. They’re the ones who make me leave shows saying, “Man, that drummer made my day.”
6. Dave Lombardo (Slayer)
For me, Dave Lombardo is the only drummer whose energy comes across in large venues. I have seen large venues render harmless some truly great drummers: Charlie Watts, Neil Peart, Dave Grohl, Vinnie Paul. But even when I’m up in a balcony, Lombardo’s beat-pushing raises the hair on my arms. Slayer albums are too inconsistent to fully showcase his talent. Only when you see him live, playing nothing but hits, do you realize what a force of nature he is.
5. Rich Hoak (Brutal Truth, Total Fucking Destruction)
Rich Hoak is sort of a cross between Buddy Rich and Ventor. His style is organic and almost jazzy, yet he can rain down blastbeats relentlessly. No other metal drummer moves around the kit like he does. His playing looks awkward and taped together, and his anxious facial expressions only reinforce that impression. But just when you think he’s going to lose a stick/lose his way coming back to the snare/fall over on his side, he somehow manages to stick the landing. He’s a nail-biter to watch, in a good way.
4. Darren Verni (Unearthly Trance, Glorior Belli)
Few drummers are as suited to their bands as Darren Verni is to Unearthly Trance. The band depends on manipulation of noise and space, and Verni regulates these with martial rigor. Yet he also works up rumbling tribal grooves and mighty everything-at-once crashes. He’s fun to watch, as he violates Vinnie Colaiuta’s “least motion/most impact” principle, raising his hands high above his head as a prelude to drum beheading. It’s interesting that he and Unearthly Trance bassist Jay Newman joined French black metal band Glorior Belli. Will they wear their trademark baseball caps in that band?
3. Ben Koller (Converge)
Ben Koller’s drumming has probably caused thousands of dollars in hospital bills from the moshpit mayhem it creates. I’ve witnessed this multiple times. He’ll drop a d-beat or a blastbeat, and people will go absolutely berzerk. He (and the next two drummers) have that special something that turns people into teeth-gnashing, blood-spurting, stranger-punching fiends.
2. Aesop Dekker (Ludicra, Agalloch)
Aesop Dekker’s rough-hewn style is immediately recognizable within seconds. It’s muscular and literally low to the ground — no Dream Theater kit excess for him. Few things are as satisfying as when he leads Ludicra into their signature swinging grooves. He’s also another drummer who can incite crowd violence with the flick of a wrist. One blastbeat from him could powderize half the pansies tap-tapping their way through technical death metal.
1. Chris Maggio (Coliseum)
Who is this guy??? I can hardly find any information on him. All I know is that whenever I see him play, everything gets all tunnel vision-y, and I only see metal and wood and sweat for the next hour or so. He’s got lightning in his hands. Nothing super-technical, just energy that bounces and rolls tirelessly. Check out the above video for proof. It’s of his new project with Chris Owens from Lords. Evidently, Maggio recently left Coliseum. His replacement has big shoes to fill.

I hate to be the demo guy, but how's about that old Bill Ward? Check out "War pigs" live in Paris in 1970: http://www.youtube.com/watch?v=xtqy4DTHGqg
Motherfucker goes overhead on practically every beat, dude is a goddamn avalanche.
Kevin Talley auditioning for Slayer is also a sight to behold, not only was he a dead ringer for Richard Ramirez at the time, but he's got the most violent approach I have ever seen: http://www.youtube.com/watch?v=3-eH5AYV83I
Eater of Dunkin', drinker of Turkey, supporter of all things Yankees, I hail "Dah-Ren."
Here's my top 6 live drummers who do not use triggers:
6. Rick Smith (Torche)
Rick probably has the crappiest looking drum kit that you'll ever see from an otherwise up and coming band. It's hard to believe that when you hear his stellar playing on their last 2 albums and EP. His drumming is sludge filled barge to Torche's bomb string attack.
5. You (Coffins)
Seeing Coffins at Maryland Deathfest last year, they played like they were summoning the evil spirits of Hades. You's drumming is primitive, slow, hellish and dripping filthy evil.
4. Marcus Andersson (Disfear)
This guy always cites Phil Rudd as a main influence. If Phil Rudd decided to speed his drumming up, went punk, joined Discharge and abandoned AC/DC, this would be how he would sound like. A true defender of the D beat.
3. Des Kensel (High On Fire)
What turned me on to High On Fire was Des Kensel's rumbling tom intro to "Hung, Drawn and Quartered" from Surrounded By Thieves. Live, his drumming is like a marching army of evil long haired and bearded hessians about to invade your town. And he was able to achieve all of that with a single pedal.
2. Dave Witte (Burnt By The Sun/Municipal Waste/Birds of Prey, etc.)
Dave Witte is my favorite technical drummer. He brings an organic edge to an otherwise machine-like aspect of drumming. I saw him play with Burnt By The Sun at the Fireside Bowl in 2004. When he was putting together his kit after a blistering set by Yakuza, he didn't have too many pieces in his kit nor did he use triggers. His playing has a really jazzy approach, but totally different from say, Rich Hoak's. Getting him to play meat and potato drums for Municipal Waste was a no brainer. Would've loved to see him with Discordance Axis.
1. Chris Reifert (Abscess/Autopsy) BLEEEEEEGH!!!!!!! Chris Reifert's drumming is very sloppy, wild, out of control, yet very heavy. Seeing Abscess wipe the streets of Baltimore with their filth and disease ridden death metal was a huge treat. He does all that while spewing out his patented drugged up subway creep vokills. Looking forward to seeing him with the true death metal gods Autopsy next year.
"A drummer should come to kill, not to play with MIDI."
Best thing I've read all month, Cosmo. I'm going to be quoting that for a while, if you don't mind.
Good call on Dekker – highly underrated, probably because he doesn't rely on flash or technicality. His drumming is just so memorable, for lack of a better word, which is one of the highest compliments one can pay to a metal drummer these days.
Lately I've been all about Vader's (late) Krzysztof Raczkowski – Christ, what a monster that guy was.
The Black Sabbath video decapitated me, drained out all my blood and filled my veins with lava
I mean, thanks for linking.
This entry gets my love for the mere mention of Ben Koller alone. That man is a fucking maniac. Other than him, I've only heard of Rich Hoak and Dave Lombardo. Better check out the rest of these guys.
If a drummer doesn't come through in a large venue, I'd say that's the soundguy's fault.
All soundguys are assholes.
Yup Aesop and Rick from Torche are but a few of my favorites using the less is WAY MORE approach.. I will admit to using "midi" in the studio sometimes, but mostly never. Play the drums like they raped your kid sister, they won't hit you back!
Marginally metal, but he is the best
http://www.youtube.com/watch?v=IF0ZxA130u4
Des Kensel is another cat who could have made this list. I have not had the pleasure of seeing Dave Witte play live. I once saw Chris Reifert live with Abscess and was underwhelmed.
Yes, Doc was the Dave Lombardo of Vader. I have to go back and revisit those old records.
That Sabbath clip was one of the best videos I've ever seen. Also, that Maserati (I believe) clip was groovy. It reminds me that I have to check out the band more. Thanks for sharing.
I'm gonna start every day with that sabbath video for a long while.
I remember seeing Entombed on their Wolverine Blues tour and Nicke Andersson had an extremely minimal kit (since I was just a kid at the time, the first thing I asked myself when Entombed went on stage was why was Andersson's kit so small and barely had anything on it, and that the drum kit at my high school was twice the size of Andersson's kit!) and just seeing him play the living crap out of it and laying waste to pretty much everything was a sight to behold. I don't think I've seen anyone do as much on such a minimal drum kit.
Also Travis Foster of Yob plays on an extremely minimal kit as well and can work wonders around it. Basically when I watched Yob play their entire new album in their rehearsal space, I pretty much couldn't take my eyes off seeing Travis play the crap out of his drum kit.
I have a DVD with the entire 1970 Paris Sabbath show and, fuck, is it awesome. It made me appreciate Bill Ward in a whole new way.
For drummers I've actually seen live, one of the most impressive was Paul Burdette of His Hero Is Gone. Not really metal, granted, but if we're counting Converge we can count HHIG. He's really fast (ie doing double kick style stuff with a single kick pedal) and super powerful.
DAN BEHLER!
Carter from Legion (http://www.myspace.com/legionbham) is Coliseum's new drummer, and he is definitely a freak.
Graeme – Looks like I'll have to track down that Sabbath DVD.
Todd – Thanks for the link. Sounds like Coliseum's drumming is in capable hands.
It's not a 'real' DVD, just some dodgy burned thing that I picked up off ebay. Still amazing though. If you can't find it I can probably burn you a copy and mail it to you. Let me know.
Sure, I'd be interested in a burned copy, Graeme. Email me at invisibleoranges at gmail dot com, and I'll give you my address. I could trade you something…not sure what…but it can't hurt to ask!
A few years ago I saw Gene Hoglan drumming for Death and I was absolutely stunned with his performance, that?s what I call pure class!
On a side note, although Terry Bozzio isn?t exactly a metal drummer he?s a monster behind the drum kit!
Dale Crover Kills Live!
Can't agree more on Hoak…
I went with some friends to see BT and they were kind of giggling at the shambling guy setting up the small drum kit.
When the drums started they all pooped their pants simultaneously.
Kenneth Schalk of Candiria was an amazing drummer back in their mid-90's heyday:
http://www.youtube.com/watch?v=UHhY6v39NOc
Also, Danny Herrera of Napalm Death:
http://www.youtube.com/watch?v=yrozISfq8yc
Those were great videos – thanks for sharing. I wish I could have seen Schalk play back in the day. Herrera has always been a force of nature.